20 Minute Old School Pizza Burgers That Hit the Spot

Oh man, do I have a treat for you! These old school pizza burgers take me right back to my childhood – that magical combo of juicy burger and melty pizza flavors that made Friday nights special. I’ve been perfecting this recipe since I was tall enough to reach the stove, and let me tell you, it’s stood the test of time.

What makes these burgers so darn good? Imagine biting into a perfectly seasoned beef patty smothered in tangy pizza sauce, topped with gooey mozzarella and crispy pepperoni – it’s like your favorite pizza decided to crash a burger party. My mom used to make these for sleepovers, and now I make them for my own kids (who go absolutely wild for them). The best part? They come together in just 20 minutes flat.

Why You’ll Love These Old School Pizza Burgers

Listen, I know you’re gonna adore these burgers as much as I do – they’re practically foolproof! Here’s why they’ve been my go-to for years:

• Weeknight superhero: From fridge to plate in 20 minutes flat (even my hangry teenagers can wait that long!)
• Kid (and adult!) approved: What picky eater can resist pizza AND burgers in one bite?
• Two great tastes: All the juicy-beefy goodness meets that melty-cheesy pizza magic
• Your rules: Throw on mushrooms, olives, whatever floats your pizza boat – I won’t judge!

Seriously, these are the ultimate crowd-pleaser – my neighbor still texts me for the recipe every grilling season!

Ingredients for Old School Pizza Burgers

Okay, let’s talk ingredients – this is where the magic starts! Now, I know what you’re thinking: “It’s just a burger, how special can the ingredients be?” Trust me, using the right stuff makes all the difference between “meh” and “WOW!” Here’s exactly what you’ll need:

• 1 lb ground beef (80/20 blend recommended) – That 20% fat is your flavor friend, don’t you dare go lean unless you want sad, dry burgers!
• 1/2 cup pizza sauce (store-bought or homemade) – My little secret? I steal a spoonful from my kids’ leftover DiGiorno dipping cups sometimes – shhh!
• 1 tsp Italian seasoning (dried) – That little green jar in your spice rack? Yeah, that one. Give it a good sniff first – if it doesn’t smell like a pizza joint, toss it and grab fresh.
• 1/2 tsp garlic powder – Not garlic salt! We’ll add regular salt separately so we can control it.
• 1/2 tsp onion powder – The quiet hero that makes everything taste more… well, more!
• Salt and pepper to taste – I use about 3/4 tsp salt and 1/2 tsp pepper, but taste as you go – your tongue knows best.
• 4 burger buns (split, preferably sesame seed) – The seeds add crunch and that classic diner vibe. No seeds? No problem – just toast ’em extra crispy.
• 1 cup shredded mozzarella cheese (full-fat for best melt) – None of that pre-shredded stuff with anti-caking powder, okay? Buy a block and shred it yourself – it melts so much better, I promise!
• 1/4 cup sliced pepperoni (about 20 slices) – The mini ones are cute, but regular slices give you that perfect fold-and-crisp action when they cook.

Now, a quick note from my many (many!) years of burger disasters: cheap ingredients make cheap-tasting burgers. Splurge a little on the good beef and real cheese – your taste buds will thank you later when you’re licking pizza sauce off your fingers!

How to Make Old School Pizza Burgers

Alright, let’s get cooking! I’ve made these pizza burgers more times than I can count, and I’ve learned a few tricks along the way to make sure they turn out perfect every single time. Follow these steps, and you’ll be biting into burger-pizza heaven before you know it!

Shaping and Seasoning the Patties

First things first – let’s talk patties. I know it’s tempting to just glob the meat together, but take an extra minute here – it makes all the difference!

Grab that bowl of ground beef and sprinkle in all your seasonings – Italian seasoning, garlic powder, onion powder, salt and pepper. Now here’s the key: use your hands to gently mix everything together. Don’t go squeezing and kneading like you’re making bread dough! Just fold and turn until everything’s evenly mixed – you’ll know it’s ready when you see little flecks of seasoning throughout.

Divide the mix into four equal balls (I use a scale, but eyeballing works too). Pat them into 3/4-inch thick patties that are slightly wider than your buns – they’ll shrink as they cook. Pro tip: make a little dent in the center with your thumb – this keeps them from puffing up into burger balloons on the grill!

Cooking the Old School Pizza Burgers

Fire up your grill or heat a heavy skillet over medium heat – and I mean medium, not high! We’re not searing steaks here, we want these burgers to cook through evenly without burning.

Once your cooking surface is hot (a drop of water should sizzle), lay those patties down gently. Now here’s where patience comes in – leave them alone for a full 4-5 minutes! Peek underneath after 4 minutes – you want a nice golden crust before flipping.

Flip them once (just once!) and cook another 4-5 minutes. They’re done when there’s no pink in the center and the juices run clear. If you’re unsure, an instant-read thermometer should read 160°F in the thickest part. Stovetop tip: if you’re cooking inside, turn on your exhaust fan – things might get a little smoky from all that delicious beef fat!

Assembling the Pizza Burgers

Now for the fun part – building your masterpiece! First, lightly toast those buns if you like some crunch (I always do). Spread about a tablespoon of pizza sauce on the bottom bun – don’t skimp, but don’t drown it either.

Place your gorgeous burger patty right on top of the saucy bun, then pile on that glorious mozzarella cheese. Here’s my secret move: while the patty’s still piping hot, layer on the pepperoni slices and pop the whole thing under your broiler for just 60-90 seconds. Watch it like a hawk – you want the cheese bubbling and the pepperoni just starting to crisp at the edges.

Top it off with the other bun half, take a big whiff of that amazing aroma, and dig in while it’s still gloriously messy! Warning: napkins required – these beauties tend to drip with deliciousness.

Tips for Perfect Old School Pizza Burgers

After burning more burgers than I care to admit and learning from every mistake, here are my can’t-live-without tips for pizza burger perfection:

• Chill out: Pop those shaped patties in the fridge for 10 minutes before cooking – it helps them hold their shape and prevents crumbling. I stick mine right on a plate while I prep the other ingredients.
• Parchment pro tip: Making patties ahead? Stack them with parchment paper between each one – no sticking, and you can just grab and cook when you’re ready. Game changer for cookouts!
• Grease be gone: After flipping, tilt the pan slightly and use a spoon to scoop out excess grease – keeps your buns from getting soggy and prevents flare-ups on the grill.
• Cheese melt magic: Once you’ve added cheese, loosely tent with foil for about 30 seconds – melts the cheese perfectly without steaming your bun into mush.
• Thumbprint trick: Press a shallow dimple in the center of each raw patty – sounds silly, but it prevents that dreaded burger bulge in the middle!

My biggest lesson? Don’t rush the process – good things come to those who wait (especially when melted cheese is involved)!

Customizing Your Old School Pizza Burgers

One of my favorite things about these pizza burgers? You can totally make them your own! I’ve experimented with dozens of variations over the years – some winners (hello, caramelized onions!) and some… well, let’s just say my blue cheese phase didn’t go over well with the kids. Here are my favorite ways to shake things up:

• Cheese swap: Try provolone for a sharper bite or smoked gouda for something different – my husband goes nuts when I use both!
• Veggie boost: Sautéed mushrooms and onions add amazing depth (just cook them first so they don’t make your burger soggy).
• Lighter option: Turkey pepperoni cuts the grease without losing that classic pizza flavor.
• Bun upgrade: Ciabatta or brioche buns take these to gourmet territory – just toast them extra well to stand up to the toppings.
• Dietary tweaks: Gluten-free buns work great, and plant-based meat substitutes actually taste fantastic with all those pizza flavors!

The only limit is your imagination – though I’d skip the pineapple unless you’re looking to start family dinner debates!

Serving Suggestions for Old School Pizza Burgers

Oh, you can’t just slap these beauties on a plate alone – let’s talk sides! My family goes wild when I serve these pizza burgers with a heap of crispy fries dusted with garlic salt (wink). For something fresh, a simple side salad with tangy Italian dressing cuts through all that cheesy richness perfectly.

Feeling spicy? Pile on some pickled jalapeños – they add the perfect kick! And drinks? Ice-cold root beer in frosty mugs makes it a real throwback meal, though my kids swear by lemonade. Honestly, these burgers are so good they could make cardboard taste fancy, but why not go all out?

Storing and Reheating Old School Pizza Burgers

Let’s be real – these burgers taste best fresh, but life happens! Here’s how to save them without sacrificing that amazing flavor. Assembled burgers keep beautifully in the fridge for about 2 days – just wrap ’em tight in foil or pop in an airtight container (layer with parchment between if stacking).

To reheat, my go-to is the oven at 350°F for 8-10 minutes – gives you that melty cheese without turning the bun to mush. In a pinch? 30 seconds in the microwave works (though expect softer buns – I like to toast ’em after). Pro tip: freeze just the cooked patties between parchment sheets for up to a month – thaw overnight in the fridge, then assemble fresh when ready to eat!

Old School Pizza Burgers Nutrition Info

Now, I’m no dietitian, but here’s the skinny on these beauties – each burger packs about 450 calories (worth every single one, if you ask me!). You’re looking at 25g fat (hello, juicy beef and melty cheese!), 28g protein to keep you full, and 30g carbs from those tasty buns.

Fair warning – these clock in around 800mg sodium thanks to all that pepperoni and pizza sauce goodness. But here’s the thing – nutrition can vary wildly depending on your brand of cheese or how heavy-handed you are with toppings. My advice? Enjoy every messy bite and maybe balance it out with a salad tomorrow!

Old School Pizza Burgers FAQ

Over the years, I’ve gotten the same burning questions about these pizza burgers from friends and family (usually while they’re stuffing their faces). Here’s everything you need to know:

Can I make these ahead?

Absolutely! Shape those patties up to 24 hours before cooking and keep them chilled in the fridge – just separate them with parchment paper so they don’t stick together. I actually think the flavors meld even better when the seasoned meat rests overnight!

Best cheese substitute?

While mozzarella is classic, provolone gives you that same melt with a sharper kick. My Wisconsin cousins swear by white cheddar – it’s got enough fat content to melt beautifully without turning greasy. Just steer clear of pre-shredded bags (they never melt right)!

How to prevent soggy buns?

Oh, this one’s easy! Either toast your buns lightly before assembling (my go-to method), or lay down a crisp lettuce leaf as a moisture barrier. Bonus tip – wait until right before serving to sauce the bottom bun if you’re prepping ahead!

Print